In 1925, Sis. Georgiana Robinson began hosting prayer meetings in her home, forming the “Gideon Praying Band.” The group grew, and under the guidance of Rev. Maggie A. Chappell, moved to 10 East 134th Street, New York. Later that year, Rev. Frank H. Haynes took leadership and led the congregation to various locations throughout Harlem.
In 1934, Rev. William Lee Freeman joined and served on the Steward Board. After Rev. Haynes’ passing in 1935, Rev. Freeman became St. Luke’s pastor and guided the congregation for 14 years. Under his leadership, the church purchased its first home at 139-141 West 126th Street in 1937 and, in 1946, acquired the current sanctuary with a $75,000 mortgage.
Rev. Albert A. Davis became the third pastor in 1950, leading the congregation for 15 years. In 1965, Rev. Richard R. Stokes assumed leadership, overseeing various improvements and continued growth. Rev. S. Frank Emmanuel became the fifth pastor in 1978, organizing clubs, and youth groups, and purchasing the 30th Precinct Police Station, now the church’s administrative building.
In 1997, St. Luke welcomed its sixth leader, the Rev. Melvin E. Wilson. Rev. Wilson came in with a Ministry of “Teaching, Reaching and Preaching.” He instituted the Intercessory Prayer-Line, and additional Bible studies to give the members more opportunities to study God’s Word. Rev. Wilson also brought structure to St. Luke to help the church become more efficient. Under his leadership, to keep everyone informed, he instituted the email blast system to keep the members up to date on programs and projects taking place on all levels of the Connection.
On January 22, 2012, St. Luke welcomed its seventh Pastor: Rev. Marcellus A. Norris. Rev. Norris came in with a Vision and a Ministry of Excellence for St. Luke. Pastor Norris introduced to St. Luke the “E” Factor, which constitutes the Principles of Excellence in: Worship, Praise, Stewardship, Leadership, Study, Prayer, Love, Discipleship, Fellowship, and Outreach.
Under his leadership, he was able to stabilize the finances of the church. Pastor Norris established a Discipleship Course to transform members into disciples of Jesus Christ.
During his tenure, the church successfully navigated repairs and a temporary relocation due to roof damage. Rev. Norris led the congregation through the challenges of the pandemic, expanding virtual ministries. Rev. Norris was elected to the position of Connectional Director of Church Growth and Development and before he left, the Mortgage-Burning Worship Service was held on November 7th, 2021
In 2021, Rev. Stephen A. Green became the eighth pastor, reopening the church post-pandemic, enhancing virtual ministries, and launching the Abolitionist Academy and “I Love St. Luke” Day Street Fest. His tenure saw membership growth and the completion of key renovations. In September 2023, Rev. Green married Sis. Braea Tilford, who became the First Lady of St. Luke. During this time, the Legacy Tree Project was introduced, symbolizing the church’s commitment to remembering its past, honoring its present, and envisioning its future.
In June 2024, St. Luke welcomed its ninth and first female pastor, Rev. Orsella R. Hughes. Alongside her, her life partner, Bro. Howard Hughes, became St. Luke’s First Gentleman. Together, they lead with a focus on love, unity, and spiritual growth. Rev. Hughes’ first sermon, titled “The Greatest of These is Love,” emphasized the importance of love and community, both within the church and in the broader mission of Kingdom-building. Her leadership is rooted in the belief that prayer and love are essential to the church’s operations and ministry.
As St. Luke celebrates its 99th anniversary in 2024, the congregation reflects on its rich history and looks forward to future growth under Rev. Hughes and Bro. Howard Hughes’ leadership, with the Legacy Tree Project continuing as a tribute to the church’s heritage and a vision for the future. Together, they remain committed to glorifying God and equipping believers for ministry.